Quality of Earnings Analysis: What Buyers Examine Before Acquiring a Business
Discuss your financial due diligence or transaction requirements with Pensar Valuation.
A business may report growing revenue, rising EBITDA and a healthy profit margin. Its financial statements may appear consistent, and its management may present an optimistic growth forecast.
But before an acquisition, a buyer needs to answer a more important question:
How much of the reported earnings can the business realistically sustain after the transaction?
Reported profitability does not always tell the complete story. Revenue may be recognised before cash is collected. Earnings may include exceptional income, expenses that have been deferred, or costs that will need to be incurred by a new owner. Working capital requirements may be increasing, while certain financial obligations may not be immediately apparent from the headline figures.
This is where Quality of Earnings (QoE) analysis becomes important.
As a central workstream within financial due diligence, quality of earnings analysis helps buyers understand the underlying financial performance of a target business. It
examines the reliability of reported earnings, identifies adjustments required to assess maintainable profitability and highlights financial matters that may influence valuation, transaction structure and purchase price negotiations.
For an acquirer, the objective is not simply to verify the numbers. It is to understand the earnings that are actually being purchased.
1. What Is Quality of Earnings Analysis?
Quality of Earnings analysis is an examination of a company's reported financial performance to assess whether its earnings are genuine, sustainable and representative of its underlying operations.
The exercise typically begins with reported EBITDA and evaluates the adjustments needed to arrive at a more supportable view of maintainable or normalised EBITDA.
It may examine:
Revenue recognition and the quality of reported sales.
Customer concentration and revenue sustainability.
Non-recurring income and expenditure.
Related-party transactions and promoter-related costs.
Operating margins and cost structure.
Working capital trends and cash conversion.
Capital expenditure requirements.
Other financial exposures that may influence the transaction.
The scope of a QoE review depends on the transaction, the business and the information available. It is usually considered as part of a wider financial due diligence exercise, rather than as a substitute for an audit, legal review or commercial due diligence.
A key distinction is that an audit primarily addresses the financial statements within its defined assurance scope. A buyer-side QoE review is transaction-oriented: it examines what the financial performance means for the buyer, the valuation assumptions and the terms on which the acquisition is being considered.
2. Why Reported EBITDA May Not Represent Maintainable Earnings
EBITDA is frequently used in acquisition discussions because it provides a reference point for comparing operating performance before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation.
However, the reported figure may not represent the profitability that a buyer can expect to continue after the acquisition.
Consider a company reporting annual EBITDA of ₹10 crore.
At first glance, the figure may appear attractive. However, the business may have incurred exceptional transaction expenses, received one-time income, paid below-market remuneration to its promoter or deferred recurring maintenance expenditure.
Each of these matters needs to be examined before arriving at an adjusted earnings figure.
Understanding EBITDA normalisation
The following is an illustrative buyer-side adjustment bridge:
Particulars | Amount (₹ crore) |
Reported EBITDA | 10.00 |
Add: Exceptional transaction-related legal expenses | 0.30 |
Add: Exceptional plant relocation expenditure | 0.20 |
Less: One-time insurance recovery | (0.15) |
Less: Adjustment for replacement management remuneration | (0.30) |
Less: Recurring maintenance expenditure deferred | (0.15) |
Illustrative adjusted EBITDA | 9.90 |
The example demonstrates why normalisation is not simply a process of adding expenses back to increase EBITDA.
A buyer must examine adjustments in both directions.
For instance, a seller may argue that certain legal expenses were exceptional. The buyer would need to understand whether those costs were genuinely transaction-specific or whether similar costs are part of the normal operating requirements of the business.
Similarly, promoter remuneration may appear unusually high or low. The relevant question is what it would cost to retain or replace the management capability required to operate the company after completion.
Every adjustment should be supported by evidence, assessed for recurrence and evaluated in the context of the continuing business.
What makes an adjustment supportable?
A potential normalisation adjustment should generally be evaluated against four questions:
Is the item properly identified and supported by accounting records or other reliable evidence?
Is it genuinely non-recurring or outside the normal course of business?
Would the cost or income continue after the acquisition?
Has the adjustment already been reflected elsewhere in the analysis?
An adjustment is not automatically acceptable simply because management describes it as exceptional.
3. Revenue Quality: Are Reported Sales Reliable?
Revenue is often one of the first areas examined during financial due diligence.
A company may demonstrate strong year-on-year growth, but a buyer needs to understand what is driving that growth and whether it is likely to continue.
The analysis goes beyond comparing annual sales figures.
Revenue recognition and cut-off
Buyers examine whether revenue has been recognised in the appropriate period and in accordance with the applicable accounting framework.
For Indian companies applying Ind AS, Ind AS 115, Revenue from Contracts with Customers, provides the framework for recognising revenue based on the transfer of promised goods or services and the associated performance obligations.
A diligence review may therefore examine:
Sales recorded near the financial year-end.
Customer acceptance and delivery documentation.
Contract modifications and variable consideration.
Credit notes and post-period adjustments.
Unbilled revenue and contract assets.
Advances received from customers and contract liabilities.
Subsequent collections against reported receivables.
The objective is to understand whether reported revenue reflects the underlying performance of the business and the terms of its customer contracts.
Customer concentration
A business may derive a significant proportion of its revenue from a small number of customers.
This may create a risk that is not immediately visible from the overall revenue growth rate.
For example, a company reporting ₹50 crore in annual revenue may derive ₹20 crore from a single customer.
The buyer would need to understand:
How long the customer relationship has existed.
Whether there is a written contract or recurring purchase arrangement.
Whether pricing is commercially sustainable.
Whether the agreement can be terminated or renegotiated.
Whether the relationship depends heavily on the promoter or a key employee.
A major customer's departure could materially affect future revenue, margins and the valuation assumptions used in the transaction.
Revenue sustainability
Buyers may also distinguish between contracted revenue, recurring revenue, project-based revenue and prospective business opportunities.
A sales pipeline is not automatically equivalent to contracted revenue. Similarly, a business that has grown through a few unusually large orders may have a different earnings profile from one supported by a diversified and repeat customer base.
The quality of revenue matters because the sustainability of earnings depends on the underlying business activity generating them.
4. Operating Costs and the Sustainability of Margins
A company's reported EBITDA margin may be affected by cost recognition, related-party arrangements and expenditure that has not been incurred in the period under review.
A detailed analysis therefore examines the operating cost base and the resources required to maintain current business performance.
Areas of attention may include:
Promoter and related-party expenses
Are remuneration, consultancy fees, rent and other related-party charges consistent with the commercial requirements of the business?
Employee costs
Are there key positions that remain unfilled, pending increments, unpaid incentives or management roles that will need to be replaced after completion?
Maintenance and operating expenditure
Has expenditure been deferred to improve short-term profitability? Would the buyer need to incur additional costs to maintain operations?
Exceptional and unusual items
Are there unusual write-offs, provisions, reserve releases, litigation expenses or other transactions affecting reported margins?
Cost allocation
In group companies or businesses being carved out of a larger organisation, are the costs allocated to the target sufficient to reflect the resources it will need on a standalone basis?
A company that appears highly profitable under its current ownership structure may have a different cost base when operated independently.
5. Working Capital: How Much Cash Does the Business Need to Operate?
EBITDA does not measure the cash required to operate a business.
A company may report healthy earnings while experiencing pressure on its cash flows because customers pay slowly, inventory accumulates or suppliers need to be paid earlier.
This is why working capital analysis is an important part of acquisition due diligence.
A commonly used starting point for operating net working capital is:
Operating Net Working Capital = Trade Receivables + Inventory − Trade Payables
The precise definition must be agreed for the transaction and may include or exclude additional operating balances.
A buyer typically examines:
Monthly working capital balances.
Receivable ageing and collection patterns.
Inventory ageing and potential obsolescence.
Payable ageing and overdue supplier balances.
Seasonality and business-cycle requirements.
Historical movements in working capital.
Any unusual balances close to the transaction date.
Understanding the working capital peg
In many cash-free, debt-free acquisition structures, the purchase agreement establishes a normalised working capital target, often referred to as a working capital peg.
This represents the level of working capital expected to remain in the business at completion so that it can continue operating in the ordinary course.
For illustration, suppose the agreed working capital target is ₹5 crore, while the actual eligible working capital at completion is ₹3.8 crore.
The resulting shortfall is ₹1.2 crore.
Depending on the transaction agreement and its definitions, this may result in an adjustment to the consideration payable to the seller.
The important point is that the target should reflect the business's normal operating requirements rather than an arbitrary historical average.
A buyer should also consider seasonality. A company operating with high inventory requirements before a peak sales period may have a very different working capital profile from one measured during a quieter month.
6. Net Debt and Debt-Like Items: What Obligations May Affect the Purchase Price?
Another important area of financial due diligence is understanding the obligations that may influence the amount ultimately paid for the equity of a business.
In a typical enterprise-value-based transaction, the buyer may need to consider net debt and other agreed debt-like items when determining equity value.
A simplified relationship is:
Indicative Equity Value = Enterprise Value − Net Debt ± Agreed Working Capital Adjustment − Other Agreed Items
The actual calculation depends on the transaction structure and the definitions included in the sale and purchase agreement.
Items requiring attention may include:
Outstanding bank borrowings and accrued interest.
Unpaid or overdue statutory obligations.
Certain employee-related liabilities and accrued benefits.
Unpaid capital expenditure.
Unpaid transaction-related fees or expenses.
Guarantees, commitments and contingent liabilities.
Significant tax exposures and pending assessments.
Other obligations that the parties agree should be treated as debt-like.
These items are not automatically classified as debt-like in every transaction. Their treatment depends on their economic nature, the agreed definitions and whether they have already been reflected in working capital or another purchase-price adjustment.
Avoiding double counting is particularly important.
For example, an outstanding supplier balance should not automatically be deducted as debt-like if it is already included in the agreed working capital calculation.
The objective is to establish a clear and complete view of the financial obligations being assumed by the buyer.
7. Cash Conversion and Capital Expenditure: Do Earnings Translate Into Cash?
A business can report positive EBITDA without generating an equivalent amount of cash.
Cash conversion helps a buyer understand how effectively reported operating performance translates into available cash.
The analysis may consider:
Receivables growth and collection delays.
Inventory accumulation.
Changes in supplier payment terms.
Tax and interest payments.
Capital expenditure.
Other operating cash requirements.
Capital expenditure deserves particular attention.
A business that has consistently deferred machinery replacement, technology upgrades or maintenance expenditure may appear more profitable in the short term.
However, the buyer may need to invest additional capital after completion to maintain operating capacity or support projected growth.
It is therefore important to distinguish between maintenance capital expenditure, which is needed to sustain existing operations, and growth capital expenditure, which is intended to support future expansion.
The assessment also helps determine whether management's financial projections are consistent with the investment required to achieve them.
8. Forecasts: Can the Business Deliver Its Projected Performance?
Historical earnings explain what has happened. Forecast analysis helps a buyer evaluate what may happen next.
Management projections should be assessed against the historical financial performance, customer behaviour, market conditions and operating capacity of the target business.
Areas to examine include:
Revenue assumptions: Are projected sales supported by existing customer relationships, contracts, pipeline conversion and realistic pricing assumptions?
Margin assumptions: Are improvements supported by identifiable operational changes or simply optimistic expectations?
Cost assumptions: Have the costs of replacing key personnel, maintaining operations and supporting growth been considered?
Working capital assumptions: Will higher sales require additional inventory, receivables funding or other operating capital?
Capital expenditure: Does the forecast include the investment required to maintain or expand the business?
A forecast should not be accepted merely because it has been approved by management. Its key assumptions need to be challenged and linked to available evidence.
9. Tax, Contingencies and Other Financial Exposures
Financial due diligence may also identify matters that do not appear as ordinary operating costs but could affect the transaction.
Depending on the target business, these may include:
Pending income-tax assessments and tax disputes.
GST-related reconciliations and exposures.
Outstanding TDS, PF, ESI or other statutory dues.
Litigation and contractual commitments.
Related-party balances and transactions.
Guarantees and other contingent obligations.
Unrecorded or insufficiently provided liabilities.
The significance of each matter depends on the amount involved, the likelihood of crystallisation, the timing of potential payment and the relevant transaction protections.
A finding may lead to further investigation, a purchase-price adjustment, a specific indemnity, an escrow arrangement or another negotiated protection.
Financial diligence findings should be considered alongside legal and tax advice when determining how a transaction should be structured.
10. A Practical Example: How Quality of Earnings Can Change an Acquisition Decision
Consider an illustrative manufacturing business being evaluated by a potential acquirer.
The seller reports EBITDA of ₹10 crore and proposes an enterprise valuation based on a multiple of 8 times EBITDA.
At the headline level:
₹10 crore × 8 = ₹80 crore indicative Enterprise Value
During financial due diligence, the buyer identifies:
Certain transaction expenses that may qualify for normalisation.
A one-time insurance recovery included in reported earnings.
Promoter remuneration below the cost of replacement management.
Maintenance expenditure that has been deferred.
A significant working capital requirement.
Certain outstanding obligations that require specific assessment.
After reviewing the evidence, the buyer arrives at an illustrative adjusted EBITDA of ₹9.9 crore.
Using the same illustrative multiple:
₹9.9 crore × 8 = ₹79.2 crore indicative Enterprise Value
This creates a difference of ₹0.8 crore compared with the initial calculation.
The final equity consideration may then require further adjustments for net debt, eligible working capital and other items defined in the transaction agreement.
This illustration simplifies a real transaction. Actual valuation multiples, normalisation adjustments and purchase-price mechanisms depend on the business, the transaction structure and the evidence available.
The wider lesson is that a relatively small difference in maintainable earnings can influence the negotiation when valuation is based on an EBITDA multiple.
It also demonstrates why buyers need to understand the underlying earnings before agreeing to a headline price.
11. What Information Should a Buyer Review?
A structured financial due diligence exercise typically requires more than the latest audited financial statements.
Depending on the size and complexity of the transaction, information requests may include:
Information area | Examples of documents |
Financial statements | Audited financial statements and statutory audit reports |
Management information | Monthly management accounts, trial balances and general ledgers |
Revenue | Customer-wise sales, contracts, invoices and credit notes |
Receivables | Ageing reports and subsequent collection records |
Inventory | Stock statements, ageing and obsolescence analysis |
Costs | Payroll records, related-party expenses and major operating contracts |
Working capital | Monthly receivables, inventory and payable balances |
Borrowings | Loan statements, repayment schedules and security details |
Tax and compliance | Relevant tax returns, assessments, reconciliations and litigation details |
Capital expenditure | Fixed asset register, capex schedules and maintenance plans |
Forecasts | Budgets, business plans and management assumptions |
The quality, consistency and availability of this information can influence the depth of analysis and the time required to complete due diligence.
12. What Should a Buyer Expect From a Quality of Earnings Review?
The purpose of the exercise is to develop a supportable understanding of the target's historical and sustainable financial performance.
Depending on the engagement scope, the output may include:
A reconciliation of reported financial information to underlying records.
An analysis of historical revenue, margins and operating performance.
A bridge from reported EBITDA to adjusted or maintainable EBITDA.
An assessment of key revenue and customer-related risks.
A review of working capital trends and normalised requirements.
Identification of net debt and potential debt-like items.
An assessment of financial exposures and unusual transactions.
Observations on management projections and cash flow requirements.
Key findings relevant to purchase-price discussions and transaction protections.
These findings help buyers understand the financial characteristics of the business they intend to acquire.
A quality of earnings review does not, by itself, determine the final price or guarantee the future performance of the acquired business. It provides evidence and analysis that can inform the buyer's investment decision and the wider transaction process.
Conclusion: Before You Agree on the Price, Understand the Earnings
An acquisition should not be evaluated solely on the basis of reported revenue, EBITDA or management projections.
The buyer needs to understand how earnings have been generated, whether those earnings can be sustained, how much working capital the business requires and what financial obligations may affect the transaction.
Quality of earnings analysis brings these questions together.
It helps distinguish reported profitability from maintainable performance and gives buyers a more informed basis for assessing valuation assumptions, negotiating price and evaluating transaction risks.
Ultimately, the important question is not simply:
"How much EBITDA does the company report?"
It is:
"What earnings can the business reasonably sustain, what cash will it require, and what financial obligations will the buyer inherit?"
How Pensar Valuation Can Support Your Transaction
An acquisition involves more than agreeing on a headline valuation. Understanding the target's financial performance, earnings sustainability and balance-sheet exposures is essential to assessing the transaction on an informed basis.
Pensar Valuation provides financial due diligence, valuation and transaction advisory support to businesses and investors evaluating corporate transactions.
Whether you are assessing a potential acquisition, preparing for investment or seeking greater clarity on a target company's financial performance, a structured review can help establish the financial basis for the decision.
Discuss your financial due diligence or transaction requirements with Pensar Valuation.
References and Further Reading
PwC India — Buy-Side Due Diligence: https://www.pwc.in/services/buy-side-due-diligence.html
PwC — Financial Due Diligence: https://www.pwc.com/us/en/services/consulting/deals/joint-ventures-alliances/financial-due-diligence.html
EY — Mergers and Acquisitions Due Diligence: https://www.ey.com/en_gl/services/strategy-transactions/mergers-acquisitions-due-diligence
Deloitte — M&A: The Intersection of Due Diligence and Governance: https://www.deloitte.com/us/en/programs/center-for-board-effectiveness/articles/mergers-and-acquisitions-due-diligence-and-governance.html
Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Government of India — Ind AS 115, Revenue from Contracts with Customers: https://www.mca.gov.in/Ministry/pdf/IndAS115_2020_10112020.pdf
This article is intended for general informational purposes and does not constitute audit, accounting, tax, legal, investment or transaction-specific valuation advice. The appropriate diligence scope and treatment of adjustments depend on the facts, applicable accounting framework and transaction documentation.


Comments